Hacker News Way Back Machine

• App.net funded with $500,000. · 364 points · by aculver · 204 comments
• Why Explore Space? A 1970 Letter to a Nun in Africa. · 360 points · by mike_esspe · 159 comments
• Leaving Github · 229 points · by srl · 142 comments
• Rootbeer GPU Compiler Lets Almost Any Java Code Run On the GPU · 223 points · by doublextremevil · 79 comments
• Essential C · 222 points · by krat0sprakhar · 53 comments
• Erlang programmer’s view on Curiosity Rover software · 196 points · by deno · 78 comments
• Dalton Caldwell: We Did It · 178 points · by J-H · 54 comments
• The Most Important Writing Lesson I Ever Learned · 157 points · by sage_joch · 50 comments
• Sorting and searching at the library · 150 points · by nkurz · 25 comments
• What “Worse is Better vs The Right Thing” is really about · 148 points · by m_for_monkey · 46 comments
• Terms of Service; Didn't Read · 138 points · by ryanio · 14 comments
• Chill out, listen to some rain · 131 points · by andrewfelix · 79 comments
• What is life like for PhDs in computer science who go into industry? · 122 points · by gandalfgeek · 67 comments
• Cling: Running C++ in an interpreter · 113 points · by coldgrnd · 48 comments
• What has NASA done to make your life awesome? · 89 points · by instakill · 48 comments
• The making of the Sony PlayStation · 89 points · by CrazedGeek · 6 comments
• Show HN: Convert online videos to .gif · 84 points · by sgehlich · 39 comments
• First High-Resolution Color Mosaic of Curiosity's Mastcam Images · 75 points · by hybrid11 · 46 comments
• Wristwatch in only HTML/CSS · 74 points · by Flam · 35 comments
• What Ouya Isn't · 74 points · by hazzen · 46 comments
• uTorrent Becomes Ad-Supported to Rake in Millions · 72 points · by tomse · 63 comments
• Colour printing reaches its ultimate resolution · 68 points · by ananyob · 18 comments
• Working at big software companies · 67 points · by rdcastro · 21 comments
• A comparison of C++11 language support in VS2012, g++ 4.7 and Clang 3.1 · 67 points · by AndreyKarpov · 9 comments
• Monner - Monitor CPU, memory and network whilst running a program · 56 points · by colinhowe · 21 comments
• HiMom (YC S12) Helps Your Parents Keep Up With Your Life · 54 points · by martin_tipgain · 24 comments
• How Big Data Became So Big · 52 points · by sew · 5 comments
• Facebook Is The Ant; Zynga Is The Grasshopper · 51 points · by kunle · 22 comments
• Does it make you win? · 51 points · by enra · 10 comments
• Demonoid Domains Go Up For Sale · 49 points · by uladzislau · 23 comments
• Show HN: Painless, productive views on iOS with Formotion for RubyMotion · 49 points · by 10char · 13 comments
• Show HN: Prune Unwanted Stories from HN Front Page · 49 points · by latitude · 24 comments
• App.net, like I need another bug tracker · 45 points · by astrojams · 55 comments
• Facebook Porting PHP To JVM · 44 points · by code-dog · 63 comments
• Midnight project: Password manager without a password manager · 38 points · by jaseg · 41 comments
• Pyjs: a Rich Internet Application Development Platform for both Web and Desktop. · 37 points · by ColinWright · 10 comments
• Explore IBM Java 7 · 34 points · by javinpaul · 9 comments
• The computer scientist CEO · 32 points · by wheels · 19 comments
• Biological impacts of the Fukushima on the pale grass blue butterfly · 30 points · by bootload · 10 comments
• The Social Dynamics of the R Core Team · 24 points · by dangoldin · 2 comments
• The World Spends 0.2% Of Its Time On Facebook · 22 points · by matthewlmcclure · 9 comments
• Best Desktop Keyboards · 22 points · by uladzislau · 61 comments
• How many people are in space right now? (API) · 22 points · by aaronpk · 5 comments
• Freelance dev market · 21 points · by anovikov · 10 comments
• What I Learned From Russell Kirsch · 20 points · by joelrunyon · 3 comments
• Brainpad: How I get stuff done using Trello · 19 points · by tbergeron · 7 comments
• Node.js Frameworks Comparison · 18 points · by nateps · 6 comments
• IQ and Religion · 18 points · by pooriaazimi · 29 comments
• Ask HN: Weekend side projects? · 16 points · by bazookaBen · 24 comments
• Martin Fleischmann, Cold Fusion Seeker, Dies at 85 · 16 points · by donohoe · 10 comments
• My road to the IOI 2012 · 15 points · by bvdbijl · 1 comment
• App.net will be funded. · 14 points · by aculver · 3 comments
• Whats the most inspirational quote you ever heard? · 14 points · by dittes · 18 comments
• App.net is Destined for Failure · 14 points · by ruswick · 20 comments
• Handle passwords with Keychain · 13 points · by charliesome · 11 comments
• The Dark Side of JavaScript · 12 points · by Killswitch · no comments
• Backbone.js Performance Tips - cincijs August · 12 points · by cdmwebs · no comments
• Ask HN: What headphones are you using? · 12 points · by skippednote · 30 comments
• Why Ron Conway is Jazzed on Ecommerce · 10 points · by dmor · 1 comment
• Google Testing Reader Subscriptions in Search Results · 9 points · by mjfern · no comments
• Test if your website is blocked in China · 9 points · by hughesey · 2 comments
• What I learned in selling my company for $100 million · 9 points · by larrys · 2 comments
• FBI believed Kim Dotcom had a ‘doomsday device’ · 9 points · by 1337biz · 4 comments
• Pentax Si · 9 points · by saint-loup · 7 comments
• How Google+ Punk’d The Oatmeal · 9 points · by ejpastorino · 1 comment
• Statement for President Nixon to Read in Event of Disaster on Moon Landing · 8 points · by srl · no comments
• How much sleep do you really need to work productively? · 8 points · by turoczy · 1 comment
• 8 Great Resources for Learning Android · 8 points · by hash-table · no comments
• For Jennifer Sultan, a Dot-Com Bust · 8 points · by goatcurious · no comments
• Groupon Sales Force Cracks Under Pressure · 8 points · by LVB · 3 comments
• New Hampshire is building a tech cluster in Boston’s shadow · 8 points · by dgallagher · 3 comments
• Show HN: A new type of freelancer marketplace · 7 points · by 3riverdev · 7 comments
• Shadow DOM · 7 points · by pooriaazimi · no comments
• Facebook Moving To The JVM · 7 points · by bpierre · no comments
• Exeter, we have a problem · 7 points · by tokenadult · 2 comments
• Ask PG: When is the next Startup School application open? · 6 points · by trueneverland · no comments
• Apache Wicket – three years of lessons learned · 6 points · by rohshall · 6 comments
• Maybe this help porting TextMate to Linux · 6 points · by macco · 10 comments
• The Dock in Mountain Lion takes as much memory as VMware running Windows 7 · 6 points · by c3d · 2 comments
• ClojureDB - a networked document database engine · 6 points · by howardg · 2 comments
• Golden Ratio in logo designs · 6 points · by reion · 2 comments
• Bouncing Python's Generators With a Trampoline · 6 points · by beala · no comments
• Should I Use ORM Or Not? Sure. · 6 points · by sigpwned · no comments
• Wikileaks gets $37K in donations via Bitcoin · 6 points · by sathishmanohar · no comments
• The other Arab Spring: startups in the Middle East · 6 points · by joshuahedlund · 1 comment
• A Wooden White Panel, Thousands of Small Nails, and a Single Black Sewing Thread · 6 points · by huhtenberg · 3 comments
• Bitcoinica users sue for $460k in lost Bitcoins · 5 points · by Anon84 · no comments
• When will we have LINQ in Java? · 5 points · by rohshall · 4 comments
• Ask HN: What kind of toolkits have people written on top of statsd? · 5 points · by quintin · no comments
• Ask HN: How does Google uses the Go Programming Language? · 5 points · by zedzedzed · 8 comments
• Curiosity runs on a PowerPC CPU · 5 points · by cpg · no comments
• 5 commands to be a better PHP developer · 5 points · by tydeas · 3 comments
• Winners of Yahoo Open Hack 2012 India Announced · 5 points · by imkarthikk · no comments
• On Curiosity and its software : An Erlanger's Perspective · 5 points · by signa11 · 1 comment
• Why do we hear music in our heads but can't perform it or write it down? · 5 points · by zipop · no comments
• HyperCard turns twenty-five years old today · 4 points · by shawndumas · no comments
• Statistics on the go: Census Bureau releases 'America's Economy' app · 4 points · by jamesbritt · no comments
• The inverse power of praise · 4 points · by 6ren · no comments
• Happy 80th Birthday, LEGO · 4 points · by evo_9 · no comments
• Google to demote pirated content · 4 points · by yitchelle · 1 comment
• (404) npm goes down · 4 points · by iapi · 7 comments
• Computing Your Skill — An overview of the TrueSkill algorithm · 4 points · by dhotson · no comments
• Fast, Fair, and Frictionless Content Licensing On The Internet · 4 points · by iSimone · no comments
• Lego Celebrates 80th Birthday With Whimsical Animated Short [video] · 4 points · by joering2 · 1 comment
• Little Rocks On The Surface Of Mars · 4 points · by playhard · no comments
• Schemas vs. Schemaless structures and The PostgreSQL Type Farm · 4 points · by bsg75 · no comments
• How do DNS-based proxy services work (e.g. to watch the BBC olympic feed)? · 4 points · by cschmidt · 3 comments
• A Graphical Documentation System for C/C++ projects · 4 points · by AndreyKarpov · no comments
• On creative machines and the physical origins of freedom · 4 points · by aarghh · no comments
• Preparing a massively open online course (Part 2) · 4 points · by ColinWright · no comments
• Free Online Course about In-Memory Data Management from HPI · 4 points · by grundprinzip · no comments
• Python in 30 Days - Day 2 · 4 points · by rodriguezcommaj · 2 comments
• Android’s “Google Now” can teach Siri a few tricks · 4 points · by llambda · no comments
• Startups Need a Special Learning Curve for Sales · 4 points · by ichaib · no comments
• Software Development is an Apprenticeship · 4 points · by BenjaminCoe · no comments
• How to build an online presence · 3 points · by theyCallMeSwift · no comments
• Gmail results in Google Search available to beta participants · 3 points · by pavel_lishin · 1 comment
• Kosmos distributed file system · 3 points · by xal · no comments
• PON-Z, the world's first honest ponzi scheme. Using bitcoin. · 3 points · by KennethMyers · 3 comments
• An App.net / HN username list · 3 points · by hxf148 · no comments
• A Character Encoding Glitch In Messages.app · 3 points · by unixpickle · no comments
• Music Collaboration With Git · 3 points · by pcoffey · no comments
• The intelligent textbook that helps students learn · 3 points · by roguecoder · no comments
• VOIP built on Node.js · 3 points · by reubeneli · no comments
• VimGolf - Prime Numbers · 3 points · by anderse · no comments
• Facebook Groups Let You See Exactly Who Has Viewed Your Photos, Too · 3 points · by iProject · 1 comment
• Climate change: A statistical analysis shows how things really are heating up · 3 points · by frrp · no comments
• Node Package Manager Registry is Down · 3 points · by dhruvbhatia · no comments
• How Something You've Never Heard Of Is Changing Your World · 3 points · by irunbackwards · no comments
• Google Appeases Hollywood But Rankles Internet Freedom Watchers · 3 points · by jalanco · no comments
• To those who love the web · 3 points · by pascal07 · no comments
• Get Out of Your Comfort Zone and Reach Out · 3 points · by carlsednaoui · no comments
• 10 Smart Things I've Learned from People Who Never Went to College · 3 points · by aakil · no comments
• Time-wars · 3 points · by onosendai · 1 comment
• Fab failure, or, bad bad bad usability · 3 points · by matsiyatzy · no comments
• Graphene in High-Frequency Electronics · 3 points · by quasistar · 1 comment
• Another quality of a great engineer: holding state in your head · 3 points · by abhijitr · no comments
• Disable HTTP Cache With PHP · 3 points · by paulund · 1 comment
• I use a rotary phone to Tweet: words from a slow learner. · 3 points · by acoyfellow · no comments
• Easily manage your PPA in Ubuntu with Y PPA Manager · 3 points · by ricciocri · no comments
• Dalton Caldwell’s Twitter alternative App.net reaches $500,000 funding goal · 3 points · by antr · no comments
• The Universal Design Pattern · 3 points · by llambda · no comments
• Metro.css · 3 points · by pizza · no comments
• How do you get past writer's block? · 3 points · by CodeCube · 1 comment
• OpenWeatherMap - the free weather and meteo maps · 3 points · by Ukolova_olga · 1 comment
• Pure Javascript HTML weather widget · 3 points · by zenogaisis · no comments
• Show HN: Apache Wicket small auth example · 3 points · by exelib · no comments
• Jquery function demos for aspiring web developers · 3 points · by SkippyZA · no comments
• MIT researchers develop highly agile autonomous plane (video) · 3 points · by mechnik · no comments
• Create a foursquare like Back-end Infrastructure and API in 60 seconds or less · 3 points · by yorapi · 2 comments
• Sleep = Success · 3 points · by J-H · no comments
• App.net: A shortcut to critical mass · 2 points · by jharrier · no comments
• How to be a genius · 2 points · by 6ren · no comments
• EWG Joins California’s Fight To Label Genetically Engineered Food · 2 points · by zoowar · no comments
• Free Classic Books Online at Classic Reader · 2 points · by zoowar · no comments
• Nathan Myhrvoid defends patent trolling · 2 points · by ryandvm · no comments
• Wow: Craigslist loses Craigslists.com domain dispute · 2 points · by ilamont · 1 comment
• The LEGO Story · 2 points · by jamesbritt · 1 comment
• Could lasers solve the military's friendly-fire problem? · 2 points · by itsclearleon · no comments
• [tutorial]: Writing Notification Center Widgets for iOS. · 2 points · by blomange · no comments
• TEDx: 3D printed houses · 2 points · by 6ren · no comments
• CSS3 Knight Rider K.I.T.T. with Sound · 2 points · by luzon19 · no comments
• Proposed SHIELD law is nothing but a gift to infringers · 2 points · by briandear · no comments
• Everyone's a Fact-Checker · 2 points · by tokenadult · no comments
• Dalton Caldwell explains the recent hype and let downs of Silicon Valley · 2 points · by nberardi · no comments
• Your Business Ideas Are Shit · 2 points · by lylemckeany · no comments
• Taxpayers now funding anti-science Christian schools in Louisiana · 2 points · by ck2 · 1 comment
• Where the Minutes are Longer: Time on Mars · 2 points · by benaiah · 1 comment
• The startup guide to China · 2 points · by gspyrou · no comments
• State of Data This Week - #1111 · 2 points · by nilendumisra · no comments
• Life insurance viatical settlements: Funds that bet on people dying · 2 points · by hexagonal · no comments
• 17 year old develops artificial brain to diagnose cancer · 2 points · by pawannitj · no comments
• Negotiations for a 2014 WIPO Broadcasting Treaty Are Back · 2 points · by mtgx · no comments
• How to create blueprints for your OSGi building blocks · 2 points · by javinpaul · no comments
• App.net Might Change the Very Fabric of the Internet · 2 points · by puranjay · no comments
• Not So Fast: The history of management consulting · 2 points · by bao · no comments
• To Square Up the Starbucks Experience: Potentials and Potholes · 2 points · by zhiQ · no comments
• Performance of Memory vs Disk · 2 points · by AndreyKarpov · no comments
• A New Era in Transportation Systems · 2 points · by semilshah · no comments
• Physics, Topology, Logic, Computation: A Rosetta Stone (2009) [pdf] · 2 points · by gtani · no comments
• Learn how to exploit phones: Practical ARM Exploitation · 2 points · by s7ephen · no comments
• Blackhat 2012 retrospective and photojournal (from two trainers and speakers) · 2 points · by s7ephen · no comments
• App.net passes $500,000 funding goal in quest to do Twitter the right way · 2 points · by shawndumas · no comments
• Trapwire and data mining: What we know · 2 points · by recycleme · no comments
• Will anyone remember how to use a real camera in ten years? · 2 points · by J-H · 1 comment
• Radiation hardening techniques · 2 points · by geuis · no comments
• Why I'm supporting App.Net · 2 points · by ckevinc · no comments
• Disruptions: Dining With Robots in Silicon Valley · 2 points · by nickbilton · no comments
• An app for those who need up to the minute notifications about new designs · 2 points · by jm3 · no comments
• Why Great Designers Quit Designing · 2 points · by nhangen · 1 comment
• Notes on Java versus C++ Performance · 2 points · by redjamjar · no comments
• Warning to firms on Facebook comments · 2 points · by shimms · no comments
• Cognitive teardown of the user experience in Angry Birds · 2 points · by smartial_arts · no comments
• The HR-less performance review · 2 points · by czr80 · no comments
• Ask HN: What html/css framework do you use? · 2 points · by robinthrilliams · 3 comments
• Weknowyourhouse.com · 2 points · by justinholmes · no comments
• The Software Engineering Axis Survey · 2 points · by bpierre · 1 comment
• Politwoops: Deleted tweets from politicians · 2 points · by nathancahill · no comments
• Why is there no 'reserve tank' for cellphone batteries? · 2 points · by pavel_lishin · no comments
• A Plot Scenario Generator · 1 points · by EwanG · no comments
• Songza · 1 points · by SageChara · no comments
• Wall Street and the Mismanagement of Software · 1 points · by kristianp · no comments
• Ask HN: What can a CS undergrad from abroad do when visiting NYC for two days? · 1 points · by why-el · 2 comments
• The Tech Celebrity Effect · 1 points · by nickbruun · 1 comment
• An Open Letter to Youtube · 1 points · by jinfiesto · 1 comment
• 3D printer to print a house in 20 hours · 1 points · by ricksta · no comments
• Content Type Page Templates in Drupal? · 1 points · by pcoffey · no comments
• Something to think about... · 1 points · by mactac · no comments
• What It Feels Like To Be Acqhired · 1 points · by matan_a · no comments
• In China, Building a Startup at Microsoft Asia R&D HQ · 1 points · by seanmcdirmid · no comments
• Quitting Microsoft to join an Unproven Startup · 1 points · by techvibes · no comments
• JSNetworkX: NetworkX ported form Python to Javascript · 1 points · by wslh · no comments
• Facebook: A Fate More Similar To Yahoo Or Google? · 1 points · by espeed · 1 comment
• EMPORI: The original Amazon Locker from 12 years ago · 1 points · by damian2000 · no comments
• A port of the graph library NetworkX to Javascript · 1 points · by wslh · no comments
• Git A Girlfriend · 1 points · by jonthepirate · no comments
• Perseid Meteor Shower Peaks Tonight: How to Watch · 1 points · by dkokelley · no comments
• Livestream: Copenhagen Suborbitals launching space capsule in 15 minues · 1 points · by mixmax · no comments
• How to Kick Ass like Morgan Freeman: A Case Study · 1 points · by ssebro · no comments
• UCLA Scientist discovers plate tectonics on Mars · 1 points · by neya · no comments
• Olympic Physics: Diving and the Moment of Inertia · 1 points · by vmanju · no comments
• The Bullying Culture of Medical School · 1 points · by bootload · no comments
• Dispelling The Eureka Myth: Big Ideas Take Time And Space · 1 points · by iProject · no comments
• Richard Feynman: The Value of Science · 1 points · by maayank · no comments
• Why are there 100 Cents In A Dollar? Ask Thomas Jefferson · 1 points · by jc123 · 1 comment
• First Color Panorama from Mars by Curiosity · 1 points · by adrianwaj · no comments
• Yahoo Open Hack India breaks record with Largest number of Hackers · 1 points · by imkarthikk · no comments
• Reid Hoffman,Founder of Linkedin shared entrepreneurship journey at Pandodaily · 1 points · by Kyaw · 1 comment
• Apple asked Samsung to pay as much as $30 per Android phone · 1 points · by codeka · no comments
• What App.net really can be (if we let it) · 1 points · by zensavona · 1 comment
• Python in 30 Days - Day 1 · 1 points · by rodriguezcommaj · no comments
• 'Brain in a dish flies plane,' brains on Twitter are wowed · 1 points · by ValentineC · no comments
• OOP Business Applications: Trying to escape the mess · 1 points · by beberlei · no comments
• MinTwit - a minimal Twitter library for WinRT (Windows 8 Metro Style) released · 1 points · by sagar_sm · no comments
• How Advertisers Convinced Americans They Smelled Bad · 1 points · by playhard · no comments
• GladiusDB and Firebird: Databases for Your PHP Apps · 1 points · by mariuz · no comments
• Cloud APP updated to fix auto upload bug in Mountain Lion · 1 points · by HugoDias · no comments
• Future Learning Short Smells Like Soyulent Green · 1 points · by jackwest · no comments
• Show HN: Amazon live search in 7 different region · 1 points · by wintorez · no comments
• What we don't understand about religion just might kill us · 1 points · by robg · no comments
• Mascons - gravitational anomalies · 1 points · by jakeonthemove · no comments
• Erwin Schrödinger and the Quantum Revolution by John Gribbin: review · 1 points · by TDL · no comments
• Crowdfunding Gets Tricky for Amazon · 1 points · by gluejar · no comments
• Calendar - from scratch or plugin? · 1 points · by jhacks · no comments
• Ask HN: Does anyone know if demonoid users will be targeted? · 1 points · by benblodgett · 1 comment
• Demonoid Domains Go Up For Sale · 1 points · by pawannitj · no comments
• App.Net reaches it's goal · 1 points · by brianjesse · no comments
• App.net just reached the $500k · 1 points · by terhechte · no comments
• When will we forget? · 1 points · by dennisgorelik · no comments
• PandoMonthly Presents: A Fireside Chat with Reid Hoffman · 1 points · by nhangen · no comments
• Google’s Giving YouTube a Pass With Its New Piracy Provisions · 1 points · by pytrin · no comments
• Rover Curiosity Streams Live from Planet Mars with Adobe Media Server and AWS · 1 points · by Brajeshwar · no comments
• Google Copyright Transparency Report · 1 points · by MrBlue · no comments
• Stunning panoramic from Mars Curiosity - water? · 1 points · by CodeCube · no comments
• Boots To Business: Veteran Entrepreneurs Succeeding At High Rates · 1 points · by MRonney · no comments
• Your Product Chooses Your Community · 1 points · by thesyndicate · no comments
• Best Buy founder proposes $10B plan to compete with Amazon · 1 points · by evo_9 · no comments
• An Impossible To Live Up To Hero: Chuck Sweeney · 1 points · by dohertyjf · no comments
• Charlie Brooker: It's OK to shout at machines · 1 points · by nsns · no comments
• Learning from Play by Play · 1 points · by parkov · no comments
• Guide: How To Create a Start-up Product Video for $250 · 1 points · by russtrpkovski · no comments
• App.net just got funded, should you join? · 1 points · by slaven · no comments
• Introductory talk about monad transformers in scala (with slides) · 1 points · by ibotty · no comments
• Dummy: A Content Generation Toolkit for Rapid Prototyping and QA · 1 points · by clumsybull · no comments
• Agile software development myths · 1 points · by pguzmang · no comments
• A Distributed Systems Reading List · 1 points · by turingbook · no comments
• How to Get Doping Out of Sports · 1 points · by stephensikes · no comments
• Firepush: push notification and cloud messaging service for iOS & Android · 1 points · by gorkemcetin · no comments
• Interactive Graphic: The Best and Worst Countries in the Medal Count · 1 points · by ColinWright · no comments
• Spare Time Project: HiveSpun.com online art collaboration · 1 points · by torme · 1 comment
• Olympic Medals per Capita - 2012 · 1 points · by EwanG · no comments
• Teen used bb gun to rob fellow player of 4.7bn fantasy coins for RuneScape · 1 points · by DanBC · no comments
• Killing a Stackless Bug · 1 points · by wmat · no comments
• Zero Gravity Yo-Yo Tricks · 1 points · by julioademar · no comments
• The Rhode Island Computer Museum - see anything you worked on? · 1 points · by dmd · no comments
• Amazon customer support · 1 points · by vskr · no comments
• Embracing Risk in Career Decisions · 1 points · by xiaoma · no comments
• Yes, we're a contestant in CRMIdol. Are you? · 1 points · by 5Degrees · no comments
• Hey programmers who is Lena or Lenna? · 1 points · by rexyo · no comments
• Minecraft Pocket Edition Adds Bows, Skeletons and Spiders · 1 points · by Tinabeans · no comments
• Bilingualism and False Diagnosis · 1 points · by systems · no comments
• Assassins Creed 3 gets Release Date · 1 points · by Tinabeans · no comments
• The Search For The Mystical Data Scientist Should Not Be A Feat Of Magic · 1 points · by irunbackwards · no comments
• How Technology is Changing Weddings · 1 points · by herbertlui · no comments